Thanks for your opinions, it seems like player 1 is the better solution for the long-term. Just as a little more background on my situation, I train frontcourt players and I would love to keep both but I already have a great center so I have to choose between one of these players for my PF.
It looks like the plan for now should be to hold on to both until I lose in the tournament, then sell player 2 and keep player 1.