BuzzerBeater Forums

The game was a blowout. Hard to justify giving Wall any more than 2 points for being on the losing team and he got his stats in 48 minutes. Opposing Cs really only played half a game each so really if the game was a lot closer, All-Sort's starting C would have spent more time marking Wall so his stats would not have been as high.

and If's and Buts were candy and nuts.

Doesn't make sense to be an individual award when the entire teams performance has so much weight.

But whatever. :)
Gab will just have to push harder from now on.

Doesn't make sense to be an individual award when the entire teams performance has so much weight.

Well considering that the opposing C only played half the night due to the blowout, Wall's performance is not as impressive.

Its like saying Kendrick Perkins should be more valuable than Dwight Howard, when Dwight got the job done in half the night and left a Colleague kid mark Perkins for the other half of the night.

OR if Cameron Mooney played for Richmond I bet he would struggle to get at least 4 kicks a game.

well the guy that got 3 votes played 48 minutes aswell.
against someone with atrocious OD.
and had he played on an actual SF his stats would have been greatly reduced. (lets all play the "if game")
but sure, justify it how you want, appeal is over.

Oh and Cam Mooney is crap, regardless of his team. :)

See that's how it rolls. A player can only go so far without a good team.

how bout we just wait for the big cat to judge. good luck sir

I wish to appeal the following match.

http://www.buzzerbeater.com/match/36141628/boxscore.aspx

3 votes - Manogloids - Luke McCaskie - 28 points 7 rebounds 3 assists 3 steals

McCaskie has had some rough nights recently especially last week against the Gladiators when scoring came tough. Tonight was a bit of an exception shooting 12-30 for his game high 28 points. With 6 of his 7 rebounds being offensive he clearly wanted to prove his offensive value after recent performances and he deserves the 3

2 votes - Whompas Donkeys - Medartas Tvarijanavicius - 10 points 16 rebounds

The lithuanian didnt have the most impressive shooting night canning only 4 of 15, however he was big on the boards and managed double digit points.

1 vote - Mangoloids - Luca Batini - 10 points 19 rebounds

Luca shot only marginally better than Medartas and only grabbed a few more rebounds in 4 extra minutes. Not much between them but with the way the Donkeys marshalled the game they deserve to get the 2 votes imo.

Mertartas got a lesson from McCaskie who dropped 28 on him. Also Luca kept his man (Ignatio Santana, Whomp's best player) to just 6 points. Luca also had more boards. Medartas was lucky to get any token votes, let alone the two.

No idea if Rad Ranga is appealing or not, but more then happy for monkey to keep jumping in with common sense and deterring people from appealing

I think it was yoda that said the West teams are all 'business' that's why we don't appeal, either that or the complete opposite and we're the only ones who realise its just a bit of fun and only the opinion of the person putting the time in to write the report or maybe we're just not as big a sooks as the rest of u

Anyway yeah as i have no idea if crazy carrot is still appealing I'll just do Mango's for now...

This was an interesting one with the SG playing PF. But in my opinion it was pretty simple, as Mango said McCaskie gave Tvarijanavicius a bath while playing out of position. Realistically the situation should have been reversed, the big fella in an inside iso offense should have taken a SG playing at PF to town in a M2M defense but he didnt. So I agree with Mags, he was thoroughly disappointing and realistically i dont think he deserves any votes. But looking i dont think there was many other players who did. It was basically a horrible game all round so i cant find anyone else deserved of the 1 vote but I'm happy to approve the swap of Tvarijanavicius with Batini.

Tough gig doing votes for a match like that, I'd have found some lucky fans to give the 2 and 1 to as McCaskie was the only guy worthy of a vote!

So go nuts and swap it around to

3 - Luke McCaskie
2 - Luca Batini
1 - Medartas Tvarijanavicius

done.

i think ranga is serious but will have to wait and see if monkey has deterred him