Not sure if you are seriously appealing or not so I'll go through the process anyway...
Normally i would love to bring noodles down a peg at every chance i get but unfortunately as depressing as it is i agree with him on this one and I also think Ton was better then Guanzheng...
Realistically here the comparison can only be Ton v Guanzheng... The 2 big guys from the Tigers dominated their opponents and are the clear 1 and 2. So if Gaunzheng was gonna get a vote it'd be over the top of Ton. Which makes it handy as they went head to head. Forget about the result, as if we want to bring up the fact it only became a 15 point loss in the last quarter well Ton outscored Guanzheng in that quarter so who's to blame for that? If Guanzheng died in the ass when it mattered, hardly valuable.
Head to Head Ton had Guanzheng covered with Ton's 26-6-8 coming in less minutes and in a more efficient manner then Guanzheng's 28-7-2.
Common sense has to be used here, the winning team had 3 dominant performers and not much else, the losing team had more of an even contribution. Its going to be unlikely that someone from the losing team will get votes in this situation especially when the best player on that team was still outplayed by his direct opponent.
So despite all the bias towards Xie and as much as I'd like to correct noodles, Guanzheng just doesn't deserve a vote in my opinion! and that was without me even having to take into account the negative influence of the extreme sooking factor!
Guanzheng is def 4th in line and I can see why other peoples opinions might have him just slip into 3rd but thats my opinion on the matter!