BuzzerBeater Forums

Australia - IV.7 > MVP Appeals

MVP Appeals

Set priority
Show messages by
From: SplitJ
This Post:
00
175871.41 in reply to 175871.39
Date: 3/19/2011 8:37:21 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
6161
I am appealing for the http://www.buzzerbeater.com/match/32306154/boxscore.aspx

I am arguing why didnt shumkovski get the 3 votes?

mllama argument for that:

both players played equally and Still did a better job defensively as well as putting up similar score in less time.

I can argue that Shumkovski clearly had a better game even though the other C shot 4-5 since shumkovski put him in early foul trouble as well as getting 3 more asts, 2 more steals and a block while shooting 4-5 from the strike so there's an and one in there as well. If you believe in the +/- system then Still had the lowest +/- system so his defense wasnt that good? also the other PF was clearly having a bad night since my backup PF

MIN FG 3FG FT +/- OR TR AST TO STL BLK PF PTS
C N. Shumkovski 30 5 - 10 0 - 0 4 - 5 +14 3 11 4 2 2 1 0 14 13.5
PF P. Still 27 7 - 12 0 - 0 0 - 0 +8 4 11 1 0 0 0 1 14 11.5
PF M. Szczypiór 21 6 - 9 0 - 0 2 - 3 +17 0 5 2 2 1 1 0 14 8.5

I believe that still didnt even deserve a vote rather than 3 votes since shumkovski is clearly 3 with my backup PF and Still fighting it out for the 1.

From: iwen
This Post:
00
175871.42 in reply to 175871.1
Date: 3/19/2011 8:54:58 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
345345
I'm not sure it is reasonable to allow appeals for games that were from previous rounds. That appeal is for a game 2 rounds ago. If you have an appeal, get it done before the next game.

From: mllama

This Post:
00
175871.43 in reply to 175871.41
Date: 3/19/2011 8:57:17 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
326326
Can we really appeal against games that were more than a week ago?

What is with all the appeals against me this week? sheesh...

Still had lower +/- cause he played less minutes. Can't read anything into that.

Their points and rebounds are identical. When you take into account foul shots, their scoring efficiency is identical.

Shumkovski had more assists, but also more TOs.

The only real difference I could spot between them was the fact that one's opponent went 3-11, and the other went 4-5. Based on that I think this one is clearcut, and there is nothing here that justifies an overturn (unless of course, we want to argue that Sznajder deserves the 3)

This Post:
00
175871.44 in reply to 175871.43
Date: 3/19/2011 9:00:13 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
522522
You are really getting hammered with appeals this week!!!

This Post:
00
175871.45 in reply to 175871.44
Date: 3/19/2011 9:02:48 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
345345
You started it..

From: C-Cat

To: iwen
This Post:
00
175871.46 in reply to 175871.45
Date: 3/19/2011 9:22:11 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
101101
Yeah pretty sure when this appeal business started it was mentioned it has to be appealed in the current week.

So I'm not gonna touch this unless Yoda comes in and tells me I'm crazy and making things up and that wasn't actually said...


A lot of appeals lately and most could have gone either way. Why cant everybody just love everybody? and be grateful for the effort the voters go to!

From: yodabig

This Post:
00
175871.47 in reply to 175871.46
Date: 3/19/2011 9:53:05 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
14651465
Yes sorry we did say there was a one week limit from the time the MVPs are published for appeals to be lodged. So sorry we will not be able to investigate this appeal. Otherwise it would just encourage everyone to appeal decisions in the last couple of weeks if there had ever been anything not 100% the whole season. C-Cat has cup championships to lose, he is a very busy man. Just kidding, C-cat we alredy discussed 2nd is better than 502nd.

Leeroy we did publish all the appeals rules somewhere. Just find them and we will both know where they are. This is the one down side of this not being a federation, not being able to sticky stuff. We just need Dire to gibe us one sticky links thread...

Last edited by yodabig at 3/19/2011 9:55:46 PM

This Post:
00
175871.48 in reply to 175871.45
Date: 3/19/2011 10:42:16 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
522522
Lies :P

From: SplitJ

This Post:
00
175871.49 in reply to 175871.43
Date: 3/19/2011 10:47:11 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
6161
The only real difference I could spot between them was the fact that one's opponent went 3-11, and the other went 4-5. Based on that I think this one is clearcut, and there is nothing here that justifies an overturn (unless of course, we want to argue that Sznajder deserves the 3)


are you serious? 4-5 was agaisnt my 9k backup C since he didnt even get any shots off in the first half. only 1 guy was scoring - sznajder and he was shooting like 39% until he came up against my scrubs. so blocks and still dont matter? if he played lower minutes which is 3 mins less, why do you give him so much credit for defense then since my PF who play 21 mins would also get a lot of credit for that. 3 more assist 2 more TO also 2 steals as well. also shumkovski beat his man at boards and cause him to TO 5 times.

I have been meaning to appeal just that I wrote that I didnt have the time to do so.

From: zyler

This Post:
00
175871.50 in reply to 175871.49
Date: 3/19/2011 11:52:01 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
217217
rules are rules :)

From: tremell
This Post:
11
175871.51 in reply to 175871.50
Date: 3/20/2011 12:03:03 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
224224
Man i love the fishbowl PL, you even have a way of disputing mvp votes without getting kicked out of the league!

Advertisement