Wolph wanted to say the following to shoot down my smack in flames.
'You like many people have no CLUE about secondaries. You simply can't handle the numbers you look at 2 or 3 primaries and make a judgement on the value of players. You can't see holes, you can't figure TSP. You can't see the salary versus the production.
Marchi is a very rare build. Look on the TL for any center with 5+ in every single guard skill JS,JR,OD,PA,HA,DR..without a hole, then look at that JS. How many Cs have that JS? That is why he sold for that, cuz he worth it.
Goncz. Look at the salary. Look at the JR/PA...Look at IS ID. Now go on the list and find all these similar guards, they don't exist. There are about 50 guards with 10 or less JR a day. Or guards with 13 plus JR and 150k salary. Salary under 100k, PA over 12, JR over 12.. throw in ID of 9 and IS 5+...This is the kind of things you can't see but I can
My response.
I can get any random collection of stats from any good player and say go find exactly that and you wont.
Try to find a player with wondrous + OD, tremendous + HA/DR, prolific + PA and strong + SB salary under $40k. None.
Try to find a player with prodigious + JS/DR, tremendous + OD/HA and prolific + PA salary under $30k. None.
Try to find a player with tremendous + JS/OD/HA/DR/PA salary under $30k, there is 1 (listed for $2.2 million), add in at least mediocre + for all secondaries. None.
These are my 3 guards. I can't find 1 guy on the TL like any of them. Are they all worth $1,777,777 each? Not a chance.
Marchi didn't seem that rare to the 50,000 other users who didn't think he was worth more than $700,000 6 months ago when prices were much higher overall and he was younger. Perhaps you and your buyer are the only 2 that can see these magical skills that double his value. He is listed as a C but has mediocre PF skills, big deal.
Goncz. I can see his stats right now so who are you kidding? Look at that JR/PA you say. Yeah? Ok the JR is too high. The PA is really good for a SG but far from amazing. Look at the IS/ID you say. The IS is the same as an 18 year old draftee and the ID I already commented on. So which secondary am I blind to that you can see so clearly? He is good weekly value with those skills I would have thought he would be more like 100k a week at least. He has exacly 3 things that set him out from the normal $500k guys, good PA, great ID and cheap. But considering he is being sold for triple the TPE and at least double what he is really worth, saving $20k a week on salaries is not really worth an extra $1 million up front.
I always agreed that Patryk Madany is a top player and I'm surprised he hasn't been snapped up yet. Worth double Marchi or Goncz any day.
By the way I saw Alija Dutina in the bin, very good defensive player.
Last edited by Lord Toranaga at 8/2/2012 6:15:00 PM