Sorry for my English!
Well if you ask me...
In real life, I guess one coach will preffer to get one player with good ingame experience.
Well, this coach maybe will have to choose between one new Roster with gift to score nonstop, and one experienced"old Roster".
The first one will make much more fauls than the experienced one... , but maybe, he will be able to score if the screen is on.
The second one, will use his own expierience and will be able to make this screen by own, and score without fauls.
conclusion:
one expierenced player with IS 8lvl skill(for example) will be able to score more than one non-experienced player with IS 10lvl skill .
This is my own opinion. And one again sorry for my English